“Shakedown artist”: Josh Gotlib and Meyer Orbach sue Jona Rechnitz for alleged defamatory campaign

The pair behind Black Spruce and GO Residential accuse Jona Rechnitz of a defamatory campaign aimed at forcing a payout.
“Shakedown artist”: Josh Gotlib and Meyer Orbach sue Jona Rechnitz for alleged defamatory campaign (square)

A 20 percent slice of distributions from a multifamily portfolio now sits at the center of a $175 million lawsuit (since dropped), a notice of fraud litigation, letters to a Canadian securities regulator, a message to a synagogue president and a new defamation suit.

“Shakedown artist”: Josh Gotlib and Meyer Orbach sue Jona Rechnitz for alleged defamatory campaign

Multifamily investors Josh Gotlib and Meyer Orbach, the pair behind Black Spruce Management and GO Residential REIT, are suing Jona Rechnitz. They allege he has run a defamatory campaign against them to force a payout. Rechnitz says his communications were legal and are part of pursuing what investors are owed.

If you raise outside capital, sit on the GP side of a JV, or have ever signed a side letter that carves out a promote or a distribution split for a third party, this is worth ten minutes. I’ll walk through what’s alleged, how the money is structured, and the operator lessons I’d take from it. None of the allegations here have been proven, and I’ll keep them labelled that way.

How the Money Was Wired

The dispute traces back to one investment. TRD reports that Floyd Mayweather Jr.’s Vada Properties invested about $32 million in 2024 with Gotlib and Orbach’s affiliated multifamily portfolios, including GO Residential REIT and others run by Black Spruce.

A firm connected to Rechnitz, Frist Apex, was entitled to 20 percent of the distributions from that investment.

ItemDetail
InvestorVada Properties (Floyd Mayweather Jr.)
Amount investedAbout $32 million (2024)
VehiclesGO Residential REIT and other Black Spruce portfolios
Contested slice20% of distributions, owed to Frist Apex
Mayweather’s May claimRechnitz diverted $175 million in funds
Status of that claimDropped in late September, no explanation given

That 20 percent is the whole fight in miniature. Everyone involved agrees it exists. Nobody agrees who should be holding it.

The Timeline, Step by Step

  1. 2024: Vada Properties invests about $32 million with the Gotlib and Orbach portfolios. Frist Apex is entitled to 20 percent of distributions.
  2. May 2026: Mayweather sues Rechnitz, alleging he diverted $175 million from him, including by steering that 20 percent cut to Frist Apex.
  3. The middle: Black Spruce tries to hand the contested 20 percent to the court to hold while Mayweather and Rechnitz sort it out. Rechnitz and Frist Apex push back, calling it stalling and demanding the money plus financial documents and records.
  4. Late September: Mayweather drops his claims against Rechnitz and Frist Apex. His attorney, Leo Jacobs, declined to explain why.
  5. Late September onward: Gotlib and Orbach allege Rechnitz begins messaging their contacts.
  6. This week: Gotlib and Orbach file suit. The case was first reported by The Promote.

What the Complaint Alleges

According to the complaint as reported by TRD, Rechnitz allegedly:

  • Messaged Gotlib and Orbach’s professional contacts in late September, allegedly writing, “There’s a lot of fraud.”
  • Sent a message to the president of Gotlib’s synagogue about potential litigation.
  • On Thursday, sent a notice from Frist Apex to GO Residential REIT that the firm would bring litigation related to fraud.
  • Sent similar allegations to the Ontario Securities Commission and the Toronto Stock Exchange, the REIT’s regulators.
  • Messaged “a member of the real estate press.” TRD notes those alleged messages match emails it received.

The plaintiffs’ lawyers didn’t soften their framing:

“This is a calculated money grab. Rechnitz has sought to manufacture disruption to Plaintiffs’ ongoing business and use that disruption to harass and extort Plaintiffs into paying him.” — Lawyers for Josh Gotlib and Meyer Orbach, in the complaint

Both Sides, In Their Own Words

A spokesperson for Gotlib and Orbach also pointed to Rechnitz’s criminal history. He pleaded guilty to wire fraud in 2016, and in 2019 he was sentenced to five months in prison and five months of house arrest for honest services wire fraud tied to directing bribes to New York police officers. The spokesperson called him “a shakedown artist” and said he has “a trail of unpaid judgments and unpaid debts.”

Rechnitz’s position is just as direct. He maintains Frist Apex is owed distributions and has been stonewalled. “Floyd [Mayweather] and Frist have yet to receive the proper financials, have yet to receive the proper tax reporting, or transparency from Black Spruce and Josh,” he told TRD.

So one side calls it extortion. The other calls it a reporting failure. A court will decide which, if either, is right. I’m not going to.

What I’d Take From This as an Operator

Set the personalities aside and this is a story about counterparty risk inside the cap table. Here’s what I’d be thinking about:

  • Third-party distribution rights are a liability as well as a cost. A carve-out paid to someone other than your LP gives that party standing to demand money, records and reporting. If the LP and the third party later fall out, you’re standing between them.
  • Interpleader-style moves buy time, not peace. Black Spruce’s attempt to hand the 20 percent to the court is a defensible way to avoid paying the wrong party. It also lets the other side call it stalling. Expect that argument.
  • Public vehicles widen the attack surface. Because GO Residential is a REIT with regulators in Ontario and on the Toronto Stock Exchange, there were regulators and an exchange to write to. A private fund would not have offered those pressure points.
  • Reporting is the first battlefield. Rechnitz’s core complaint is about financials, tax reporting and transparency. Clean, timely, documented reporting to every party with an economic interest is the cheapest defense a GP has.
  • Diligence the people behind the entity. Frist Apex was the entity. The dispute is about the person connected to it. Know who’s on the other side of every side letter.

Why NYC Capital Markets Should Care

In my experience, multifamily sponsors who raise money from family offices, athletes and their advisers often take on finders, introducers and fee-sharing arrangements. Most never become a problem. When one does, it rarely stays private. Here it allegedly reached securities regulators, a stock exchange, the trade press and a house of worship within a couple of weeks.

For a GP, the reputational cost of a fight like this can outrun the dollar amount in dispute. A 20 percent share of distributions on a roughly $32 million investment is real money. Losing an investor’s confidence or drawing a regulator’s attention costs far more.

The Bottom Line

A $32 million investment, a 20 percent carve-out, a $175 million diversion claim that has since been dropped, and now a defamation suit. Every one of those numbers traces back to how a single deal was papered and who was promised a slice of it.

The allegations on both sides are unproven. The structural lesson isn’t: every economic interest you grant is a relationship you’ll have to manage when things go wrong.

How do you structure finder or introducer economics so they can’t become leverage against you later? I’d like to hear from GPs and LP counsel in the comments, and follow me for daily breakdowns of the NYC deals and disputes that move the market.

Source: The Real Deal.

Discover more from V Global Holdings | New York real estate. Special situations. Straight answers. Since 2006.

Subscribe now to keep reading and get access to the full archive.

Continue reading

At V Global, our fundamental principle is to provide the highest level of personalized service to each of our clients. We are committed to helping you achieve your goals through expert guidance and strategic solutions tailored to your unique needs. Our track record of success is a testament to the value we place on building long-term relationships based on trust, integrity, and exceptional service.

We invite you to schedule a free consultation with us to discuss your specific needs and explore how we can help you achieve your objectives. Our team of experienced professionals is dedicated to delivering results that exceed your expectations and help you reach your full potential. Contact us today to learn more.

Newsletter

Sign up to our newsletter